Phi Phi or Phang Nga Bay: Two Different Days
Both leave Phuket in the morning and both come back at dinner time. Almost nothing else about them is the same.
Phi Phi is a swimming day across open water
The Phi Phi group lies about 45 kilometres south-east of Phuket, out in the Andaman Sea. Four tours here make that crossing, and all four are speedboats or a power catamaran because anything slower would eat the day. Reckon on an hour each way at speed, in open water, with the boat slamming if there is any swell at all.
What you get for it is colour and water: Pileh Lagoon between vertical cliffs, a snorkel stop chosen on the day for visibility, an hour and a half on Phi Phi Don with lunch, and a beach hour on Khai. Four tours, four slightly different orders of the same stops.
Book this if the point of the day is being in the sea. Skip it if anyone in the group is a nervous sailor between June and October.
| What changes | Phi Phi day | Phang Nga Bay day |
| Crossing | About 1 hour of open sea each way | 30 to 45 minutes in sheltered water |
| Park fee | 400 THB, included on 2 of 4 tours | 300 THB, included on both tours |
| Main activity | Swimming and snorkelling | Canoeing, caves, sightseeing |
| Monsoon behaviour | Rough; stops get dropped | Sheltered; runs in most weather |
| Landmark | Maya Bay (closed 1 Aug – 30 Sep) | James Bond Island (open year-round) |
| From | $43 to $76 | $75 to $149 |
Phang Nga Bay is a scenery day in sheltered water
North-east of Phuket the sea turns into a shallow basin studded with limestone towers, mangrove channels and caves you enter lying flat in a canoe. The crossing is short and the water is protected by the islands, so this is the route that keeps working when the Andaman is up.
The six-island circuit is the fullest version: Ko Yao Yai, the Panak caves, canoeing at Hong Island, lunch in the stilt village of Koh Panyee, James Bond Island and a last swim at Naka. Its 4.8 from 2,616 reviews is the strongest evidence base on this page after the sunset cruise.
The sunset cruise is the other shape entirely — a big catamaran with day beds and a DJ, kayaks at Hong Island, and dinner served as the light goes. It is by some distance the most expensive day here, and the only one that gets you back after dark.
Which one if you only have a day
Take Phang Nga Bay between June and October, when the Phi Phi crossing is at its worst and Maya Bay is either closed or unswimmable anyway. Take Phi Phi between November and April, when the sea flattens out and the water clarity that the snorkel stops depend on is at its best.
If you want both and have two days, do them in that order — the Phi Phi day is the more tiring of the two, and the bay makes a better recovery day than a warm-up.
One more consideration nobody mentions on the listings: the 7 Wonders tour states plainly that it is not suitable if you have a flight, a cruise or an evening appointment the same day. Hotel drop-off after the boat lands can take another hour and a half in Phuket traffic. Take that seriously on any of these tours, not just that one.